hybrid human-electric agile monorails

Home
Consumption Factor
Gores Nobel Speech
Thats Life
Design and Development
Urban Ecological Amp
New York Biosphere
Two Futures
Genesis
Talking Points
Links
Contact Us
About Us
Site Map
Stuffed
Brain Power
Solar Grand Plan
Millenials
Chinas Silver Lining
MagneMotion
Mutually Assured Connect
Farewell Fair Weather
Best Is the New Worst
A Little Science in Your
Urban Least Emissions
Allied to Cap Carbon
World Upside Down
Bikes in Spotlight
Uno Cycle
Last Traffic Jam
Woman in Charge
Natural Blueprint
New New City
Questions for Enrique
Dymaxion Man
Scorpions for Breakfast
Roping the Sun
Meet the Intraterrestrial
Strong Paper
Electro Shock Therapy
China Increases Lead
Rowing Is Invigorating
Scraping the Sky
No Car Park Avenue
test20080618
Bike Transport
Green Coal Baron
Climatologist Call to Act
Quick Climate Change
Rethinking Country Life
Who Owns Central Park
Metal Recycling Up
Bicycle Pedestrian Course
Solar Sell
Freezes Solar Energy
Worldport by UPS
Eureka Check
Road To Ikea
Terrible Bust
Island in the Wind
Weeds and Climate Crisis
Trails Less Traveled
Eave of Independence
Energy Policy Asleep
Cause for Alarm
NYC Waterway Freight
First Flying Saucer
G8 Climate Division
Brooklyn Barely Notices
GM Solar Spain
Open to Growth
Cheap Bicycle Rentals
Withdrawal Symptoms
Wilsons Law
Russians Abandon the Ice
Gore Urges Change
Challenge to Repower
Geezers Doing Good
Texas to Tel Aviv
Whiplash
Can This Planet Be Saved
Stinging Hint of Oceans D
Two Hopes on Energy
Carbon Strength Record
Cement from CO2
Learning to Speak Climate
No Car Saturday
Flush with Energy
New Neutrino Hunt
SUV Traffic Jam
Running on Fumes
Electric Bikes Selling Br
California Large Solar
Gut Reaction
Psychology of Climate Cha
Protests Cheapest Car
Fish or Foul
Bike Safety in Numbers
Curbing Coal Emissions
New York Survival Strateg
Google and GE
Tech Frees Our Minds
Truthiness Comeback
Goose Bumps
No Laughing Matter
Otherize Obama
Art of Darkness
Coal A Tough Habit
Tunnel Views of Future
CO2 Speeds Up
Powerful Workout
First A Nap
McCains Suspension
Sound No Fury
Green the Bailout
Urban Farm Genius
Financial Crisis Fix
Rescue Capitalists
Beyond Tipping Point
Steel and Backbone
Road Just for Cars
Gordon Does Good
Migratory Barrier
Worm Grunting Solved
Killer Economy
California Green Jobs
Rebranding with Obama
Spending Stalls
Brains Secret Ballot
Nature and the Second Law
When Consumers Capitulate
Specter of Deflation
Human Factor Left Out
Tears to Remember
Up Up and Away
GM Bailout
Chief Tech Officer
Obama First Months
Morning After
War on Brains
Climate for Change
How to Fix a Flat
Brooklyn Biotech
Depression Economics Retu
Good for the Army
High Priced Gas Saves
Dangerous New World
Driven Bus or Train
Secretary of State
Bike Fitter
Rethinking Transportation
Reinventing Red Hook
WMD Found
Irony Is Dead Again
Change Is Old Hands
Chinas Industry Brakes
Cyclocross Returns
Lest We Forget
Big Auto
Dark Side Whisper
Cars Not Close
Cool Factor
Raising World IQ
CO2 Danger Zone
As More Eat Meat
Car Talk
Car Talk
Obama Pledges Public Work
While Detroit Slept
Consider the Refrigerator
Still An Emergency
Green Power Broker
Green Collar Jobs
Lean Machine
Le Tour Insulation
Slump Jolts Toyota
Real Auto Bailout
Halt Road Projects
Reboot America
Bike Iditarod
Obamas State
No Big Plan
Barack Be Good
Passive Houses
Stop Being Stupid
Win
Fifty Herbert Hoovers
Sustainable Matters CUNY
Unsustainable Mobility
Surge Waning Bikes
New Bike Lane Row
New Financial World
Innovate More Jobs
Pitch for Mass Transit
Greening the Ghetto
Earl Blumenauer Cyclist
Thinking About Transporta
Radical in Whitehouse
Obama Inaugural Address
Build Your Dream Car
Clearing the Air
Obama Stimulus Win
National Shame
Cycling Electronics
Crash Reshapes America
NYC Higher Temps Seas
IBM Rural Broadband
Start Up Risk-Takers
Power From the People
Microsoft Jetson Future
Power From The People
Inflection Is Near
Culture Warriors Fired
Google Free Phone
Civil Heretic Dyson
Brain Not Green
Street Vending Jobs
Velodrome Queens
Retrofitting Old Building
Affordable Salvation
Smarter GPS
Defecting to Faith
Here Comes the Sun
How Character Corrodes
Fuel Cells For Cars Stopp
Far From Over
Bush Torture Obama
God Talk Part 2
Detroit Charts New Course
Industrial Policy in Auto
Math and The City
Honk Honk Aaah
Who Says Innovation
Case For Manual Labor
Our Crumbling Foundation
Quitting the Car Habit
Clean Energy Milestone
Bike Messenger
Human Equation
Boiling The Frog
George Bliss
Bike Snob
How To Lick A Slug
Anger Has Its Place
Rewarding Bad Actors
Climate Security
Health Care Hullabaloo
Moving Walkway and Metro
Indian Farewell To Povert
Pubert of Scale of Planet
Mobilizing to Save
Rebranding America
Goldmans Dime
Smart Roads
New Untouchables
HurricaneForcing
French Ideal BikeShare
Not New But Improved
Recovery for Some
Infernos on Earth
American Catastrophe
Regulated Inspected Licen
Gaias Evil Twin
Stability 350 To 450 PPM
Plug-in Hybrids
AGrowingDisaster
Who Needs The Grid
Climate Postcards
Denmark In The Wind
South Africas Fire Kingdo
The Penguins Of Brazil
In Japan Concerns Blossom
Dangers Of An Overheated
Adapt Or Die
Will Big Business Save Th
An Affordable Truth
Optimism As Artificial In
A Fearful Price
We Have A Real Emergency
PlugIn Hybrids Decades Aw
Green Giant
Ice Melting Faster Everyw
Super Carbon
Americans Doing More
Insane Society
Climate Counter
Failing Like A Buggy Whip
Courts As Battlefields In
Chinese Leading The Way T
US Government Plans To Re
Never Heard That Before P
How To Reform Our Financi
Pentagon To Rank Global W
Time Is Running Out
Postcard From Yemen
New York Traffic Experime
Shani Davis On Edge
Korea Eyes 45 Billion Dol
Algae To Solve The Pentag
Tea Party Movement Lights
American Speedskater Shan
Global Weirding Is Here
Textbooks That Professors
Science Versus Snake Oil
Google Maps Add Direction
The New Rove Cheney Assau
Justices Will Prevail
Big Banks For Big Governm
Beyond Politics Ray LaHoo
In Health Bill Obama Atta
Early Humans Used Brain P
A Library That Most Can O
GM Envisions Networked Mi
For Some Cycling Eases Pa
Northeast Hit By Record G
Start Ups Not Bailouts
Rails To Trails Conservan
Jhong Bicycle Culture Rev
New York Aint Seen Nothin
Building A Green Economy
Using Brains Over Budget
Airport Crisis Spreads As
Ice Plumbing Is Protectin
An Open Mind
Dorothy Height Unsung Her
Challenging China In Rare
A Case For And Against El
Challenges Inherent In Te
The Secret Power Of The S
The Crisis Comes Ashore
Chinas Soaring Energy Use
NYC DoT Sustainable Stree
Peak Oil Coming Sooner Th
Here Comes The Neighborho
An Urban Farming Pioneer
The Little Black Piezoele
Reclaiming The Streets
Teachers Unions Last Stan
The Old Enemies
An Unnatural Disaster
Prosecuting Crimes Agains
United Emirates Build Fir
Arctic Death Spiral
East Coast Greenway
Politically Incorrect Gui
Security Tops the Environ
A Tricky Balance For Oil
No Longer Anchored Antarc
Defense Experts Want More
Record Number of US Compa
Death Doom And Distructio
Arctic Sees Record Sea Ic
Climate Change May Exacer
Easter Seals Project Acti
Bicycle Highways
Fourth of July 1776_1964_
As Oil Industry Fights Ta
China Fears Consumer Clas
US Bicycle Route System B
Traffic Remains Top Injur
Climate Change Biggest Re
Change Coming Slowly On C
Masters Of Main Street
The Pundit Delusion
The Good News About Mel G
Hauling Cargo No Car Nece
Our Beaker Is Starting To
A Fast Paced City Tries T
Highlights From HUD DoT E
Remembering Stephen Schne
A Russian Warning On Retr
Obamas Overdue AIDS Bill
DoT Celebrates Americans
US Dot Secretary La Hood
No Matter How You Cut It
We Are Gonna Be Sorry
Deutsche Bank CO2 Emissio
You Will Never Believe Wh
Shirley Sherrod And Me
There Is A Battle Outside
The Big Green Buy
SAICs Yez Concept Car Neg
Two Hundred Dollars Vs Fr
Four Deformations Of The
Richard Branson Invites S
Has A Warming Russia Outp
America Goes Dark
Ten Most Inventive Compan
Millions Of Barrels Of Oi
Climate Scientists Agree
In Weather Chaos A Case F
Moscow Through A Cloud Of
Deadliets For Walkers Mal
The Sun Also Surprises
Apple Introduces Us To Th
API Economist Oil Taxes A
Our Mosque Madness
Needed A New Economic Par
A 600 MPH Maglev Train Wh
NASA Partners To Revoluti
Climate Change Basics III
Horizon Fuel Cell Technol
Disaster At The Top Of Th
Covert Operations
New Yorker Exposes Koch B
The Billionaires Bankroll
The Brothers Koch Rich Po
The City That Ended Hunge
The Big One
Just How Environmentally
FedEx Makes More Efficien
Social Costs Of Transport
 
 



July 29, 2008
News Analysis

Climate Experts Tussle Over Details. Public Gets Whiplash.

 

When science is testing new ideas, the result is often a two-papers-forward-one-paper-back intellectual tussle among competing research teams.

 

When the work touches on issues that worry the public, affect the economy or polarize politics, the news media and advocates of all stripes dive in. Under nonstop scrutiny, conflicting findings can make news coverage veer from one extreme to another, resulting in a kind of journalistic whiplash for the public.

 

This has been true for decades in health coverage. But lately the phenomenon has been glaringly apparent on the global warming beat.

 

Discordant findings have come in quick succession. How fast is Greenland shedding ice? Did human-caused warming wipe out frogs in the American tropics? Has warming strengthened hurricanes? Have the oceans stopped warming? These questions endure even as the basic theory of a rising human influence on climate has steadily solidified: accumulating greenhouse gases will warm the world, erode ice sheets, raise seas and have big impacts on biology and human affairs.

 

Scientists see persistent disputes as the normal stuttering journey toward improved understanding of how the world works. But many fear that the herky-jerky trajectory is distracting the public from the undisputed basics and blocking change. “One of the things that troubles me most is that the rapid-fire publication of unsettled results in highly visible venues creates the impression that the scientific community has no idea what’s going on,” said W. Tad Pfeffer, an expert on Greenland’s ice sheets at the University of Colorado.

 

“Each new paper negates or repudiates something emphatically asserted in a previous paper,” Dr. Pfeffer said. “The public is obviously picking up on this not as an evolution of objective scientific understanding but as a proliferation of contradictory opinions.”

 

Several experts on the media and risk said that one result could be public disengagement with the climate issue just as experts are saying ever more forcefully that sustained attention and action are needed to limit the worst risks. Recent polls in the United States and Britain show that the public remains substantially divided and confused over what is happening and what to do. Some environmentalists have blamed energy-dependent industries and the news media for stalemates on climate policy, arguing that they perpetuate a false sense of uncertainty about the basic problem.

 

But scientists themselves sometimes fail to carefully discriminate between what is well understood and what remains uncertain, said Kimberly Thompson, an associate professor of risk analysis and decision science at Harvard.

 

And, Dr. Thompson said, the flow of scientific findings from laboratory (or glacier) to journal to news report is fraught with “reinforcing loops” that can amplify small distortions.

 

For example, she said, after scientists learn that accurate, but nuanced, statements are often left out of news accounts, they may pre-emptively oversimplify their description of some complex finding. Better, but more difficult, Dr. Thompson said, would be to work with the reporter to characterize the weight of evidence behind the new advance and seek to place it in context.

 

To support clarity, Stephen H. Schneider, a climatologist at Stanford, helped create a glossary defining what is meant by phrases like “very likely” (greater than 90 percent confidence) in the reports from the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. In a news media universe where specialized reporting is declining and a Web mash-up of instant opinion and information is emerging, Dr. Schneider said, it is ever more important for scientists to take responsibility for communicating in ways that stick, while sticking with the facts.

 

Dr. Thompson said climate science presented particularly tough challenges, given the long time lag before the worst effects kick in and the persistent uncertainty about the likelihood of worst-case outcomes. She said the news media sometimes overplayed the uncertainty by balancing opposing views in a story without characterizing the overall level of confidence in either side. And sometimes they do the opposite, sacrificing accuracy for impact, she said.

 

“Words that we as scientists use to express uncertainty routinely get dropped out to make stories have more punch and be stronger,” she said, adding that those words are important to include because “they convey meaning to readers not only in the story at hand, but more generally about science being less precise than is typically conveyed.”

 

Public-relations offices at leading scientific journals and hubs for research also could do more to avoid overplaying incremental research results, she and several other experts said.

 

Donald Kennedy, a Stanford professor emeritus who was the editor in chief of the journal Science from 2000 until earlier this year, said the flow of papers on climate, glaciology and relevant ocean sciences greatly increased in his tenure. “I do think we grew more sensitive to the need for critical review of papers likely to initiate or continue the kind of controversy that results in a whiplash effect,” Dr. Kennedy said.

 

Roger A. Pielke Jr., a political scientist at the University of Colorado, warned that the focus by the public and media on the stream of evolving climate science could distract from the need for policies now that made sense regardless of uncertainties. “The example of reducing losses to hurricanes is a good one,” Dr. Pielke said, “where the actions that make the most sense are really independent of the debate over greenhouse gases and hurricane behavior.”

“The same might be said for many health studies on fat, coffee, carbs,” he added. “The lesson from experts is to eat a balanced diet and get plenty of exercise,” which stays the same despite the various disputes.

He said his advice for scientists who wanted to “dampen the whiplash effect” was to “discuss the ‘So what?’ implications of the work explicitly, rather than leaving that step to advocates or politicians, or reporters.”

 

Increasingly, scientists are taking their message straight to the public. Realclimate.org, Climatepolicy.org and Climateethics.org are among Web sites where issues are explored in an ongoing way, rather than in response to news releases and scientific papers. Other new Web ventures, like ClimateCentral.org at Princeton and the Yale Forum on Climate Change and the Media, focus on improving media coverage.

 

Robert J. Brulle , a sociologist at Drexel University, said it was hard to be optimistic about such efforts. “In this public sphere,” he said, “it is assumed that the better argument, backed up with solid scientific evidence, will prevail.” He said many studies had shown that people tended to sift sources of information to reinforce existing views.

 

Morris Ward, the editor of the Yale effort (yaleclimatemediaforum.org), says that it will be up to the public to choose to be better informed on momentous issues that do not fit the normal template for news or clash with their ingrained worldviews. “At some point,” he said, “the public at large has to step up to the plate in terms of scientific and policy literacy, in terms of commitment to education and strong and effective political leadership, and in terms of their own general self-improvement.”